Understanding
Comics: The Invisible Art
by Scott McCloud
Chapter 4: Time Frames
How much time is represented within a single panel?
How much time is represented between two panels?
What cues help you determine this?
How do the words/sounds in a panel give you an
indication of time?
In what way does panel and gutter size and shape
impact time in comics?
How does a bleed affect your perception of time?
Consider the various ways in which motion can
be represented within a comic panel.
What do motion lines tell you? How have they evolved?
What is subjective motion?
Chapter 5: Living In Line
How can internal or subjective states, like sensation,
emotion and thought, be represented in the comic medium?
How do comics use one sense to represent all senses?
How is this related to Expressionism in art?
Extra credit:
Bring in a drawing (non-representational) that illustrates a mood,
feeling, or emotion. Share it with the class and we'll see if they
can guess what you have drawn.
How can the lines of the comic art convey meaning
and feeling?
Could you draw a happy line? A sad one? A lustful
one?
What things can squiggly lines convey?
How and why do comics make the invisible visible?
How is our vocabulary of comic emotion and sensation
culturally specific?
What can backgrounds tell you about a character
or a storyline?
What can you do with a word balloon? What other
representational choices do you have?
How do words and images interact and coexist in
comic art?
Why do we wean children off picture books?
How do popular understandings of fine art and
literature affect the reception of comics?
Consider some of the different ways in which words
and pictures might contribute to storytelling in a comic work? In
what ways are they used in Watchmen?
Which is your favorite ice cream story?
Watchmen by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons
General:
Watch for repetition of themes and images (like
"Who Watches the Watchmen")?
Study the use of space and frame (remember Joe
and the varying uses of 9 little boxes).
Consider the kinds of transitions used in the
text.
What elements of film style are invoked?
Be aware of the emotional and perceptual participation
required in your reading.
What relationship does the text have to image
throughout? Does it vary?
What do the chapter titles and the closing quotes
contribute to your reading?
What about the text at the end of each chapter?
The splash page? The clock?
What kind of world is this? How is it similar
to or different from our own?
What is the greatest pressure and threat facing
this world?
How is this world layered?
What is going on with representations of race
and gender?
What makes a costumed crime fighter a superhero,
a vigilante, or a nut case?
Notice how the word balloons contribute to characterization.
Chapter 7: A Brother To Dragons
What is Laurie doing in Daniel's basement?
How has Daniel's interest in birds and in Arthurian
legend contributed to his former life as a costumed crime fighter?
How is he able to afford all this? Does he remind
you of any popular comic characters?
What kind of costume messes you up? How and why?
What do the goggles allow you to see? Is this
a metaphor?
Who or what is always watching them?
How does the juxtaposition of the newscast and
their conversation impact the story?
How is the world edging toward war?
Notice the comic book writer. Why is he on the
news?
What is Nostalgia?
How does the report of Adrian's performance comment
on Dan and Laurie's foreplay?
Why are they unsuccessful in their coupling?
What does Dan's dream reveal about him?
Costumes, the war, and impotence (real and figurative),
discuss.
Why do they take Archie out? What do they do?
Is this foreplay?
Do costumes make it good?
What are they planning to do next?
Blood from the Shoulder of Pallas
How does this article meld a love of nature with
a sense of wonder and a desire for the transcendence?
What does this tell us about Dan?
What do Hollis and sally talk about? Notice the
Nostalgia?
How does the Black Freighter comic seem to comment on developments in our story?
Who is Big Figure? Is he a typical comic super-villain?
What does it mean to peek at the next month in
your calendar? What kind of personality characteristic is this?
How do Nova Express and
New Frontiersman serve
as commentary on each other?
Where is Max Shea? What does he think he is doing?
How do the various scenes (the newspaper, the
island, the pumpkin, the newsstand, Rorschach in jail) above the
start of Dan and Laurie's expedition function in the story?
Why does Rorschach want to use the restroom? How
does this function as a sly commentary on super-hero stories?
Why does Rorschach use the term "uniform"
rather than "costume"?
Why does Jon come for Laurie?
Why is Hollis attacked? What do the images for
his prime offer to the emotional impact of this scene?
New Frontiersman
What kind of paper is this? What values do they
espouse?
How do they represent racism and xenophobia?
What additional information are you given about Max Shea and Hira
Mannish?
Chapter 9: The Darkness of Mere Being
Why is Nostalgia the splash page? Is the repeated
presence of the perfume bottle a non-sequitor? Why or any not?
How is travel with Jon represented? What does
he forget about Laurie's needs?
How does Jon explain his relationship to time?
What does he ask Laurie to recall?
How is the snow globe significant as a metaphor?
Why are Sally and Larry fighting? What do you
hear? What doe little Laurie hear?
Who does Laurie think is her father?
Is Jon surprised to hear that Laurie and Dan are
together?
What does Laurie's memory from when she was thirteen
tell us?
How does Jon contrast the geological formations
on Mars with life on Earth? Which does he favor and why?
How does Laurie try to convince him of her viewpoint?
What kind of new perspective on the 1966 meeting
does Laurie's memory offer us?
What does the Comedian tell her? What do we hear?
Why is Jon unimpressed?
How is the fog on Mars connected to the smoke
from a cigar in 1973?
What does Laurie slowly come to realize from the
patchwork of her memories?
What changes Jon's mind? How is this possible?
Smiley face!
Sally's Clippings
What do we learn from Sally's clippings?
Who was Hooded Justice really with?
Were Mothman and Bill together?
What does Sally mean when she says costumed crusading
attracts a specific type? How might sexuality be implicated in this?
Chapter 10: Two Riders Were Approaching
Keep your eyes open for Apocalypse references
in this chapter.
What is Nixon up to?
Why does Rorschach decide not to punish his landlady?
What is Adrian doing in costume? Is it a uniform
for him? Something else?
How does he interpret media forces?
How do Daniel and Rorschach differ in their approach
to crime fighting?
How is "coming home" for Daniel and
Rorschach contracted with the return home in Black Freighter?
Are we like the horses?
What is important to Rorschach? To Daniel? How
does the information they get in the bar affect each of them?
What happens to the boat? Why?
What kind of foreshadowing do we get in Adrian's
office?
To whom does Rorschach mail his journal?
How are messages misunderstood in this section?
Adrian's Files
What kind of action figures would Adrian prefer
for the new line? Why?
Why ditch Nostalgia for Millennium? What kind
of word view is implied in each?
Chapter 11: Look On My Works, Ye Mighty É
What does the splash page represent?
How are insanity and intelligence linked problematically?
How does Black Freighter
end?
How is the story of Adrian's life typically comic
book? Typically heroic?
What kind of Age of Illumination does he want
to bring about?
Why are Joey and Aline fighting? Is it significant
that the relationship book is titled Knots?
What does Adrian do with his servants? With his
tropical oasis in the snow?
What makes Daniel and Rorschach feel like "ordinary
people?"
Why does Adrian describe his entire plot to them?
At what point does this turn into a joke about comic book villains?
What does Gloria want from Malcolm? Why can't
he give it?
How do the newspaper vendor and the kid finally
connect?
What is Adrian's plan? How does he distinguish
a symptom from the disease?
What would the true end of the world mean?
What cost is Adrian willing to incur?
What happens in New York?
How is the blank whiteness of the final panel
in this chapter different from the whiteness of the first?
After the Masquerade
Humanoids?
How is a superhero defined?
How does Adrian describe Rorschach? Do you agree?
Why does Adrian dream of a world with new problems?
What kind of "end of the world" does
he claim to desire?
Chapter 12: A Stronger Loving World
What visual and emotional content do the full
page spreads convey?
How are you affected?
How does Laurie respond? Jon?
Why is Rorschach able to believe Adrian when Daniel
cannot?
Is Veidt a superhero or a super-villain?
Why does Jon refer to Osterman as a different
person?
How does the media (and the world) respond to
the events in New York? Is this realistic? Does it offer echoes
(or rather foreshadowing) of global response to 9-11?
What decisions do our characters make about their
knowledge?
Why is Rorschach's choice different?
How do they each respond to the event? Why?
What does Jon decide to do? What does he say about
endings?
Why Hollis? What does the visit to Sally signify?
Can you reach an understanding of Sally's life
and decisions?
How is New York different now?
How has even the graffiti changed?
How does the last page echo the first? What uncertainty
hangs over the scene?
Do you think there such a thing as an ending?
If so is this a happy one?