Potential Topics for the
Short Paper
Your Choice
Select a topic of particular interest to you using
at least one of the works we have covered in class so far. This should
be a topic with some relation to themes important to the texts we
have read. Consider revising a response paper. Look back over our
reading questions.
Human Relationships with Technology
On the first day
of class we watched a scene from Modern Times
that demonstrated a 1936 look at the relationship between human beings
and technology (informed by the assembly line, mechanization, and
Taylorization). Many of the other works we have read have also offered
commentary on how human beings in different times and locations have
understood, questioned, or refashioned their relationship to technology
(consider, particularly "The Cyborg Manifesto," "The
Girl Who Was Plugged In," Frankenstein, etc.). Select at least one of the works we have read
so far and examine how they present our relationship to technology
and what this relationship might mean.
The works we have read contain many characters who
are somehow "other." These "others" can take many
forms (Frankenstein's creature, robots, cyborgs, women). Their "otherness"
often has its basis in race, class, or gender, as well as more extreme
physical difference. What function does the other serve? How might
the other define or impact the center? Can the other speak? Is the
other non-human? Does the other serve to define the human? Can an
"other" be a hero?
Representation of desire in relation to technology
has certainly been a theme in many of the works we have read (the
creature, Helen O'Loy, P. Burke, the Patchwork Girl). Examine sex
and sexuality in one of our works in terms of technology. Are love,
sex, and desire represented as aligned with or anathematic to technology?
What about desire for the technological? What might any of this mean?
In several texts nature is presented in contrast to
science or civilization (consider Frankenstein,
Songs of Innocence and Experience,
etc). What does it mean to understand the world in these different
ways? What does each philosophy offer? How do the natural and the
technological interact? What is the location of the human in all of
this? Is there a divine presence? How is respect for or domination
over nature represented in these texts? Why?
Consider the relation of any of our texts to their
particular historical moment (Patchwork Girl in terms of 1995, Blake's poetry and the Romantic period, etc.) Why were
these stories told at these particular times? What lessons did they
have for their audience? What anxieties do they reflect? How are these
texts rooted in history? Are they applicable to any time period? How?
Consider an adaptation of one of our texts. You may
choose a direct or indirect adaptation (a film of Frankenstein, a cyborg story, etc.). Examine the adaptation in relation
to the original. How are the tellings different? What cultural and
historical difference might these changes demonstrate? What decisions
are being made?
Consider the relationship between a text's message
or meaning and its format. Some examples of this might be examining
the impact of the epistolary style Frankenstein,
the use of hypertext in Patchwork Girl,
the role played by illustration in Songs of Innocence and
Experience, or the use of shape and sound in the experimental
poetry. How does what it is change or influence what it says? What
layers of meaning are added?
|